Showing posts with label Monica Potter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Monica Potter. Show all posts

Friday, August 6, 2010

Saw is NOT overrated

I'd like you to take a journey with me, if you will. We're going to go back in time, but don't worry, we won't be gone that long. We're going to 2004 specifically. Why 2004, you say? Because that is when the first Saw film came to theaters and helped define horror for the new generation.

This is the poster I have and it's AWESOME.
With a new Saw film coming out every year, people have forgotten a time before Saw, a time when this was a truly original horror film to behold. The many sequels, some good and some bad, have somewhat bastardized the series and the oversaturation in the media has led many to come to the conclusion that Saw (the original) is that most horrible word - OVERRATED.

No. It's not.

It may have just not been your cup of tea, but you cannot doubt the originality and effectiveness of the first film, as a horror film and as a sort of thriller-mystery.

I remember the time before Saw came out - I remember seeing the trailers on TV for this new horror film and getting more and more excited to see it, despite not really knowing much about it. The only indication of the plot, really, from the trailers was Cary Elwes' line, "He doesn't want us to cut through our chains, he wants us to cut through our feet." That line alone was enough to get me into the theater. The concept of the film seemed so different; you had to wonder where a story with that kind of premise could go.

Cary Elwes rules. And I think he knows it. Cocky bastard.
I remember the experience of sitting in the theatre and watching Saw. I went to see it with my friend Katie (hi, Katie) and I think we both saw ourselves as smart movie watchers. But this movie, for lack of a better phrase, had us both by the balls. We were squirming in our seats, talking to the screen, and had to pick our jaws up off the floor at the end. I distinctly remember as the screen goes black at the end, and you can still hear Adam's screams from the bathroom, Katie and I both turned to each other slowly with the exact same expression of shock on our faces. We were both prompting Monica Potter's character to kill Zep - actually saying, out loud in the theater, "Shoot him. SHOOT. HIM!" Very uncharacteristic, especially for me. And the scene where Adam is using his camera as a flashlight in his apartment? Oh, gosh, I about jumped out of my seat. Zep standing over the little girl on the bed covered in a bed sheet? Intensely creepy, and freaked me the fuck out.

The point is: I don't have physical reactions like this to movies, even horror movies, very often. Whatever it was that made Saw different, it had me. How did this movie work so well? Even looking back on it (several thousand times), I can't see what it was. Nothing can compare to that first time I saw it and that is why I still love it to this day. Horror films have to work on first impression and that is often how I judge them. My first impression of this film was better than any other horror film I had seen in a long time.

I asked Katie, the friend who saw Saw with me at the theater, if she remembered the experience. Somehow, I knew she would. I find out now that she's not a particularly big horror fan, but she wanted to see this movie, too. Here's what she had to say: "I remember being repulsed by both the film's gore and Jigsaw's sadism while simultaneously being fascinated by the whole experience's creepiness and horror. I wanted to look away, but I couldn't: The movie had me in its grip as an effective thriller."

Leigh Whannell and James Wan
As a wannabe filmmaker, I am also awed and inspired by the success of Saw. James Wan and Leigh Whannell were two first-time filmmakers from Australia. Leigh wrote the film (the story came from both of them) and James directed, with Leigh also starring in it, playing Adam. It was independent, fairly low budget, and shot in 18 days. I had no idea of any of that at my first viewing. They could have told me it was a 20 million dollar movie and I probably would have believed it.

And now that movie has turned into arguably one of the biggest horror franchises. Think about this - Saw was their first movie and they never imagined that it would evolve beyond even the first film. Yet apparently their simple yet highly entertaining and effective story had room to grow. And grow and grow and grow. They got the core of the sequel from Shawnee Smith's (Amanda) one little line in Saw - "He helped me." This gave root to the idea of Jigsaw's apprentice(s) and how he is (was) able to build and carry out all traps whilst suffering from cancer. And James and Leigh went from two nobody filmmakers to the hot topic of the horror industry.

Leigh in the jawtrap; from the scene
shot before the script was sold.
So in a way, this movie gives me hope. Leigh and James (I think it was mostly Leigh's writing, though) spent a long time working on the script - and not just the cool traps that are the center of the movies nowadays, but getting the story and the characters and those now iconic scenes right so that it would make, as Katie says, an effective thriller. And when they brought their script to America to sell it and get the money to do it right, they had people that were hella interested in it. They even shot a scene from the movie to show producers what kind of style they were going after. Smart budgeting and scheduling allowed them to get top-notch talent like Cary Elwes, Monica Potter, and Danny Glover. And now the movie is already in horror film history. It can happen, people. Those with the determination and the talent can make things happen for themselves, a concept that is pretty foreign to me right now. Still, thinking about what happened with Saw, and other films by first-time filmmakers, does give me that little glimmer of hope.

Billy, the famous Saw puppet, built
by James Wan
Is Saw perfect? Looking back on it now, with my very critical movie eye - perhaps not. Yeah, it's got plot holes (I looked up people's negative reviews of Saw and what a lot of them saw as "plot holes" were in fact not plot holes - learn the definition, dipshits) and the characters do dumb things sometimes, but that's only when you really nitpick the movie. As aforementioned, horror films have to work on a visceral level - if your guts and your body tell you that it's freaking you out, then it's GOOD. And my guts told me that Saw was one of the best damn things to happen to horror in a long time. I can't say the same for all the sequels; however, I am still amazed and how far they have taken a story that was never intended to make it past the first installment. It's unreal.

I will always be a Saw lover and supporter no matter how many sequels (hopefully, number 7 will be the last... I love Jill Tuck!) and copycats come out. It was the right film that came out at the right time and gave horror fans a dose of what they have been missing. And the blood hasn't stopped running since.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

My favorite horror remake

The third and final classic horror film remake on my list is my personal favorite, although not necessarily the best. The Last House on the Left remake is perhaps a better film cinematically in my belief, however, I still contend that The Texas Chainsaw Massacre is the best because it was much more successful and popular and appealed to a much wider audience.

This is probably going to be very long because I love this movie so much, so I apologize right now!

The Last House on the Left is another Wes Craven classic and was in fact his very first feature film. He had a very intriguing story inspired by an Ingmar Bergman film (The Virgin Spring), but perhaps not all the resources at the time to make the best adaptation of his vision. The resulting film was a shocking and violent gore-fest that put the country in a tizzy. People went absolutely nuts over this movie. It received an X rating when first sent to the ratings board and was banned in several countries for many years. Roger Ebert, however, liked the movie (yet he railed against I Spit on Your Grave - I don't get it), and over the years it has gained more credibility and admiration and is now considered a classic.

But classic or no, there was definite room for improvement on this film. Another first film by a first time director with a low budget and no-name actors. All of that turned out well, though. Some of the actors were in fact very impressive in their roles - David Hess as the leader of the gang Krug, and Lucy Grantham as Phyllis stand out the most to me. No, the biggest problem I have with the film is in terms of story.

Okay, for those that have been reading this and have no idea what this movie is that I'm talking about, here's a synopsis of the original. Two teenage girls, Mari and Phyllis, go into the big city one night to go to a concert. Trying to score some weed from a guy on the street, they end up in the clutches of a murderous little "family" of convicts. After some rape and humiliation in the woods, Phyllis is stabbed to death and Mari is shot. The convicts are left without a car and seek help at a nearby house which happens to be the house of Mari's parents. The parents discover what happened to their daughter and seek bloody revenge on the gang.

In my opinion, this basic storyline is a fantastic one to explore. However, Craven misses a few beats along the way. First of all, the scenes of rape and humiliation are interspersed with comical scenes of two bumbling sheriffs as they search for Mari, who has been reported missing by her parents. Craven has explained, and I certainly understand, his intent with these scenes - to create some uncomfortable-ness in the viewer by juxtaposing these horrific acts of brutality with an almost Three Stooges reenactment, with some wacky 70s music to go along with it. I don't think this was the best choice for the film. The second part of the film, the revenge by the parents, is completely dependent on the initial crime. It would have been so much more effective to concentrate on getting the emotion out of the audience for what happened to these girls, to make them so sad and pissed off at the people that hurt them that they will totally go along with the father taking a chainsaw to the guy who raped his daughter.

This is the main part where the remake succeeds. The story was stripped down to the basic emotional elements - here's the crime and here's the revenge. The first scene is the murderous gang busting Krug out of a police car and brutally killing the two police officers, so we immediately see how despicable these people are and just what they are capable of. The Collingwood family seems very loving, but have experienced some trauma recently from the death of a son. Mari does not die in this remake, so their revenge on her rape and attempted murder is more about protecting her and salvaging the remaining parts of their already torn family.

The other part of the film that was greatly improved upon was the scene of the discovery of Mari after her attack. In the original, Mari's dead body is found by her parents near the lake. The scene is literally less than minute long with hardly any real believable emotion by the parents over their daughters death. Boom, she's dead, next scene. They spent longer on the scene where the sheriffs get a ride from the chicken lady! The remake takes the scene much more seriously. In both films, the father, John, is a doctor but he actually gets to use his skills to try to save his daughter's life in the remake. This makes for an extremely emotional scene of him cauterizing her bullet wound, sticking a tube in her side to fixed a collapsed lung, and, as he's checking her for other injuries, discovering that she was raped.

Tony Goldwyn is fantastic in this scene, in the whole movie really. He's a talented actor that I had all but forgotten about and I'm so glad that he chose to do this movie (he was hesitant at first because of the violence). I'm still on the fence about Monica Potter in the role as the mother because at times it seemed like she almost didn't want to be there, to be in the movie, but then at times her crying and emotion was very believable. I'm not sure if it's not just her style of acting, though. She gives the same kind of awkwardness in the only other movies I recall seeing her in, Saw and Con Air. Going into the movie, I was most excited to see the actor playing Krug and if he could be as good as David Hess. Garrett Dillahunt does not disappoint as Krug. He's apparently played a bad guy before and it seems to be his forte. A mustache and beard and some black hair and totally looks the part of a bad-ass - but thankfully, not a bad-ass that you sort of like, which would have ruined the movie. He is a bad guy that you never like right from the start. He taunts the policeman in the beginning as the man is dying, he treats his son horribly, it's his decision not to let the girls go when they have a chance, he stabs Paige, he rapes Mari, and he shoots Mari. He has no respect for human life, therefore the audience has no desire to see him live. I would love to see this actor in more stuff.

I could go on and on about the directing and cinematography in the film as another way it improved on the original. I think, however, that the improvements in story were more important in the remake being about 10 times better than the original. I will say that I was incredibly impressed by the camera angles, composition, coloring, and just overall cinematography in the film. Some people look at me weird when I call this a beautiful film, but it really and truly is. There are also other things I could talk about, like responding to the controversy about the violence in the film, but that is perhaps left to another blog.